Gatsby Shoes Review 2023 | Is Gatsby Legit or Fake?

In this article, you will find in-depth Gatsby Shoes Reviews.

Gatsby Shoes, a name that’s been making waves in the realm of online footwear retail, has captured the attention of style-conscious individuals seeking a blend of elegance and everyday ease.

With a range of styles, from casual to business, Gatsby Shoes offers a promise of smart aesthetics and comfort, but as with any purchase, the decision should be an informed one.

In this comprehensive exploration, we will dive into the world of Gatsby Shoes, dissecting aspects like design, quality, comfort, and customer service, all aimed at helping you make an educated choice. 

In this review, I will share my thoughts on Gatsby Shoes and whether or not they are worth the investment.

So get ready for Gatsby Shoes reviews.

History of Gatsby Shoes

Gatsby Shoes is a shoe company that specializes in creating high-quality, stylish shoes for men. The company was founded in 2018 and has quickly gained a reputation for producing some of the finest shoes on the market.

The company was started by a group of shoe enthusiasts who were frustrated with the lack of options available to men when it came to high-quality, stylish shoes. They decided to take matters into their own hands and create a company that would produce shoes that were both fashionable and functional.

From the beginning, Gatsby Shoes has been committed to using only the finest materials and craftsmanship in the production of their shoes. Each pair of shoes is carefully crafted by hand, using only the best leather and materials.

Over the years, Gatsby Shoes has become known for their attention to detail and commitment to quality. Their shoes are now sold in stores all over the world, and the company has developed a loyal following of customers who appreciate the craftsmanship and style of their shoes.

Overall, the history of Gatsby Shoes is one of passion, dedication, and commitment to quality. The company has come a long way since its founding, but its commitment to creating the finest shoes on the market has never wavered.

Gatsby Shoes Reviews (Important Points)

Design and Aesthetics

I was impressed by the design and aesthetics of Gatsby shoes. The shoes have a classic and timeless look that can be dressed up or down. They come in various colors, including black, brown, and tan, which makes it easy to find a pair that suits your style.

The shoes are made of premium quality leather and materials, which gives them a luxurious feel. The leather is soft and supple, and it molds to your feet over time, making them more comfortable with each wear.

One thing I really appreciate about the design of Gatsby shoes is the attention to detail. The shoes have elegant silhouettes with clean lines and minimal embellishments, which gives them a sophisticated and refined look. The stitching is precise and neat, and the soles are well-crafted and durable.

Another thing I like about the design of Gatsby shoes is their versatility. They can be worn to the office, a wedding, or a night out on the town. They look great with a suit, dress pants, or jeans, which makes them a versatile addition to any wardrobe.

Overall, I think the design and aesthetics of Gatsby shoes are top-notch. They are well-crafted, stylish, and versatile, which makes them a great investment for anyone looking for a high-quality pair of shoes.

Comfort and Fit

When it comes to shoes, comfort, and fit are two of the most important factors for me. I was pleasantly surprised by the level of comfort and fit of Gatsby shoes.

The shoes are made with premium quality leather and materials, which makes them soft and flexible right out of the box. I didn’t experience any discomfort or irritation even after wearing them for a full day.

The fit is also true to size, which is always a concern when shopping for shoes online. I appreciate that Gatsby provides a size chart on their website, which helped me find the perfect fit.

Additionally, the shoes have a cushioned insole that provides extra support and comfort. This is especially important for me as I have flat feet and often experience foot pain.

Overall, I am impressed with the comfort and fit of Gatsby shoes. I can confidently wear them for long periods of time without any discomfort or pain.

Durability and Quality

When it comes to shoes, durability and quality are two of the most important factors to consider. After all, nobody wants to spend money on a pair of shoes that will fall apart after just a few wears. So, how do Gatsby shoes stack up in terms of durability and quality?

First and foremost, it’s important to note that Gatsby shoes are made with premium quality materials. The company sources only the best leather and other materials to ensure that their shoes are not only stylish but also built to last. This attention to detail is evident in the construction of the shoes themselves. From the stitching to the soles, every aspect of the shoe is carefully crafted to ensure maximum durability.

In addition to the quality of the materials and construction, Gatsby shoes are also designed with comfort in mind. This means that they are not only durable but also comfortable to wear. The insoles are made with cushioned foam to provide support and prevent foot fatigue, while the outsoles are designed for maximum traction and grip.

Of course, as with any shoe, the durability and quality of Gatsby shoes will depend on how well they are cared for. Proper maintenance, such as regular cleaning and conditioning, can help to extend the life of the shoes and keep them looking great for years to come.

Overall, I am confident in the durability and quality of Gatsby shoes. The company’s commitment to using only the best materials and construction techniques, combined with their focus on comfort, make for a shoe that is both stylish and built to last.

Price and Value

When it comes to purchasing shoes, price and value are two important factors to consider. Gatsby Shoes are not the cheapest shoes on the market, but they are also not the most expensive. The price point for Gatsby Shoes ranges from around $100 to $200, depending on the style and materials used.

While some may consider this price range to be a bit steep, it is important to consider the value that Gatsby Shoes provide. These shoes are made with high-quality materials and are designed to be both stylish and comfortable. Additionally, Gatsby Shoes are built to last, meaning that you won’t have to replace them as frequently as you might with a cheaper pair of shoes.

Another factor to consider when it comes to the value of Gatsby Shoes is their return policy. While some customers have reported issues with the return process, Gatsby Shoes does offer a 30-day return policy, which allows you to return or exchange your shoes if you are not satisfied with them.

Overall, while Gatsby Shoes may not be the cheapest shoes on the market, they do provide good value for their price. With high-quality materials and a focus on both style and comfort, these shoes are a solid investment for anyone looking for a reliable and stylish pair of shoes.

Customer Reviews and Feedback

As part of my research on Gatsby shoes, I looked into customer reviews and feedback. I found that there are mixed opinions about the brand, with some customers praising the quality and style of the shoes, while others have had negative experiences with customer service and returns.

On Trustpilot, Gatsby Shoes has a rating of 3.9 stars out of 5, based on 3 reviews. One customer had a terrible experience with the return process and customer service, while another loved the ease of ordering and recommended the shoes to friends. It seems that the quality of customer service can vary depending on the individual experience.

On the Better Business Bureau website, Gatsby Shoes has 53 customer reviews with an overall rating of 2.5 stars out of 5. Some customers complained about unresponsive customer service and slow shipping times, while others were happy with the quality and comfort of the shoes.

Overall, it is clear that Gatsby Shoes has both satisfied and dissatisfied customers. While some customers have had negative experiences with customer service and returns, others have praised the quality and style of the shoes. It is important for potential customers to consider both positive and negative reviews before making a purchase.

Comparison with Other Brands

When it comes to shoes, there are numerous brands out there, and it can be challenging to decide which one to go for. In this section, I will compare Gatsby shoes with some other popular brands and see how they stack up against each other.

Gatsby vs. Allen Edmonds

Allen Edmonds is a well-known brand that has been around for over a century. They are known for their high-quality shoes that are made in the USA. In terms of price, Allen Edmonds is significantly more expensive than Gatsby shoes. While both brands offer a similar range of styles, Allen Edmonds shoes are generally more formal and less versatile than Gatsby shoes. However, Allen Edmonds shoes are known for their durability and can last for years with proper care.

Gatsby vs. Cole Haan

Cole Haan is another popular brand that offers a wide range of shoes. They are known for their comfortable and stylish shoes that are suitable for both casual and formal occasions. While Cole Haan shoes are generally more expensive than Gatsby shoes, they offer a wider range of styles and colors. However, Gatsby shoes are known for their simplicity and elegance, which makes them a great choice for those who prefer a more understated look.

Gatsby vs. Johnston & Murphy

Johnston & Murphy is a brand that has been around for over 150 years. They are known for their high-quality shoes that are made from premium materials. While Johnston & Murphy shoes are generally more expensive than Gatsby shoes, they offer a wider range of styles and colors. However, Gatsby shoes are known for their comfort and versatility, which makes them a great choice for those who are looking for a shoe that can be worn in different settings.

In conclusion, while Gatsby shoes may not be as well-known as some of the other brands, they offer a great combination of style, comfort, and affordability. While they may not be as durable as some of the more expensive brands, they are a great choice for those who are looking for a shoe that can be worn in different settings and offers a great value for money.

Gatsby Mens Shoes Reviews

I have had the opportunity to try out a few pairs of Gatsby men’s shoes, and overall, I have been quite impressed with their quality and style. Here are my thoughts on some of the shoes I have tried:

Gatsby Wingtip Oxford

The Gatsby Wingtip Oxford is a classic shoe that can be dressed up or down depending on the occasion. The shoe features a leather upper, a leather lining, and a leather sole. The wingtip design adds a touch of elegance to the shoe, and the brogue detailing is a nice touch. The shoe is comfortable to wear, and the leather sole provides good traction. Overall, I think this is a great shoe for anyone looking for a versatile dress shoe.

Gatsby Cap Toe Oxford

The Gatsby Cap Toe Oxford is another classic dress shoe from Gatsby. The shoe features a leather upper, a leather lining, and a leather sole. The cap toe design gives the shoe a sophisticated look, and the stitching adds a nice touch of detail. The shoe is comfortable to wear, and the leather sole provides good traction. Overall, I think this is a great shoe for anyone looking for a classic dress shoe that can be worn with a variety of outfits.

Gatsby Penny Loafer

The Gatsby Penny Loafer is a stylish and comfortable shoe that can be worn with both casual and dressy outfits. The shoe features a leather upper, a leather lining, and a rubber sole. The penny loafer design is a classic look that never goes out of style, and the shoe is easy to slip on and off. The leather lining is soft and comfortable, and the rubber sole provides good traction. Overall, I think this is a great shoe for anyone looking for a comfortable and stylish loafer.

Overall, I think Gatsby men’s shoes are a great choice for anyone looking for quality, style, and comfort. The shoes are well-made and feature high-quality materials, and the designs are classic and timeless. Whether you need a dress shoe for a formal occasion or a casual shoe for everyday wear, Gatsby has a variety of options to choose from.

Pros and Cons of Gatsby Shoes

As someone who has tried out Gatsby Shoes, I can confidently say that there are both pros and cons to this brand. Here are some of the things I’ve noticed:

Pros:

  • Stylish designs: Gatsby Shoes offer a wide range of stylish designs that are perfect for both formal and casual occasions. Their shoes are made with attention to detail, and the quality of materials used is impressive.
  • Comfortable fit: The shoes are designed to fit comfortably, and they are true to size. They have a cushioned insole that provides excellent support, making them perfect for long hours of wear.
  • Good value for money: Gatsby Shoes are relatively affordable, considering the quality of materials and craftsmanship that goes into making them. You get good value for your money.
  • Easy to maintain: The shoes are easy to maintain and clean. They come with care instructions that are easy to follow, and with proper care, they can last for a long time.

Cons:

  • Limited sizes available: Gatsby Shoes have limited sizes available, which can be a problem for those with larger or smaller feet. It can be frustrating to find a design you like, only to find out that it’s not available in your size.
  • No half sizes: The shoes are only available in full sizes, which can make it difficult to get the perfect fit. If you’re in between sizes, you might have to go up or down a size, which can affect the overall comfort of the shoe.
  • Shipping can take a while: Shipping can take a while, depending on your location. If you need the shoes for a specific event, make sure to order well in advance.
  • Limited color options: Gatsby Shoes have limited color options available, which can be a problem if you’re looking for a specific color to match your outfit.

Overall, Gatsby Shoes are a good choice if you’re looking for stylish, comfortable shoes that are affordable. However, the limited sizes and color options can be a drawback for some.

Is Gatsbyshoes Legit or Fake?

As a reviewer, I have come across many online shopping websites that claim to offer high-quality products at affordable prices. However, not all of them are trustworthy. In this section, I will discuss whether Gatsbyshoes is a legitimate website or not.

To determine the legitimacy of Gatsbyshoes, I conducted thorough research and analyzed various factors such as customer reviews, website design, and policies. Here’s what I found:

Customer Reviews

When it comes to online shopping, customer reviews play a crucial role in determining the credibility of a website. Upon researching customer reviews for Gatsbyshoes, I found mixed opinions. Some customers were satisfied with their purchase and praised the quality of the shoes, while others had a negative experience with the website’s customer service.

Website Design

The website design of Gatsbyshoes looks professional and well-organized. It is easy to navigate and provides detailed information about the products, policies, and shipping. The website also has secure payment options, which is a positive sign.

Policies

Gatsbyshoes has a clear return and refund policy, which is available on their website. According to their policy, customers can return their shoes within 30 days of purchase. However, customers are responsible for the return shipping cost. Gatsbyshoes also offers free shipping on orders over $50, which is a good deal.

Conclusion

Based on my research, I can say that Gatsbyshoes is a legitimate website. Although there are mixed customer reviews, the website design and policies are positive indicators of a trustworthy website. However, as with any online shopping website, it is important to do your own research and make an informed decision before making a purchase.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Gatsby shoes available in wide width sizes?

Yes, Gatsby shoes are available in wide width sizes. The company offers a variety of sizes to accommodate different foot shapes and sizes. They also have a sizing chart on their website to help customers determine the right size for their feet.

What is the difference between Gatsby shoes and Cosidram shoes?

Gatsby Shoes and Cosidram Shoes are both online footwear retailers. While they may have some similarities, they are different brands with their own unique styles and designs. Gatsby Shoes is known for their old-world craftsmanship and attention to detail, while Cosidram Shoes is known for their modern and trendy designs.

Where can I find Gatsby shoes?

Gatsby Shoes can be found on their official website, gatsbyshoes.co. They offer worldwide shipping and have a variety of styles to choose from. They also have a physical store located in New York City.

Are Gatsby shoes good for orthopedic purposes?

While Gatsby Shoes are known for their comfort and quality, they are not specifically designed for orthopedic purposes. It is recommended that individuals with specific foot conditions consult with a healthcare professional to determine the best type of footwear for their needs.

Conclusion

So that’s it for this article on Gatsby Shoes reviews.

In conclusion, after conducting thorough research and analyzing customer reviews, Gatsby shoes seem to be a decent option for men looking for a simple and smart look. However, it is important to note that there have been mixed reviews about the quality of the shoes and the customer service provided by the company.

Based on the reviews, some customers have reported that the shoes are comfortable and well-made, while others have complained about the shoes being damaged upon delivery or the confusing return/exchange instructions. It is also worth noting that the Better Business Bureau has identified a pattern of complaints against Gatsbyshoes LLC.

Despite these issues, Gatsby shoes have received positive feedback from many customers, with some praising the old-world craftsmanship and modern style of the shoes. It is important to keep in mind that everyone’s experience may vary, and it may be worth considering the reviews and doing additional research before making a purchase.

Overall, Gatsby shoes may be a good option for those looking for a simple and stylish shoe, but it is important to be aware of the potential issues and to do your own research before making a purchase.

Leave a Comment