Red Wing 1907 vs 875 (What’s The Difference?)

In the world of rugged, durable, and stylish footwear, Red Wing has established itself as a formidable contender.

With a legacy dating back to 1905, this brand has a rich history of crafting boots that have withstood the test of time, both in terms of performance and design.

Among the vast array of their offerings, most people seem to get confused between two iconic models the Red Wing 1907 and Red Wing 875.

In this article, we’ll be comparing the Red Wing 875 vs 1907. We’ll compare materials, comfort, weight, design, and more to help you decide which one is perfect for you.

So buckle up, and let’s get started!

Red Wing 1907 vs Red Wing 875: Comparison Table

For a quick overview of the key differences and similarities between the Red Wing 875 and 1907, here’s a handy comparison table:

FeatureRed Wing 875Red Wing 1907
LastHistoric 23 last (narrow)Modern 45 last (wide)
InsoleLeather footbedRemovable insole
WeltRegular flat weltFake Norwegian welt
LeatherOro Legacy LeatherCopper Rough & Tough
Eyelets & LacesNickel eyelets, two-tone leather lacesGunmetal eyelets, Red Wing branded laces
Weight64 oz67 oz
StitchingSingle stitch designThicker stitching
Comfort & CushioningAdequateEnhanced

Overview of Red Wing 1907

The Red Wing 1907 is an iconic and timeless silhouette that is synonymous with the brand’s heritage.

The boot’s moc toe and Traction Tred outsole, along with its storm welt that adds additional water resistance, are some of its defining features.

The Copper Rough & Tough leather is durable and of high quality. The secondary leather lace that comes with the boot allows you to elevate the look.

The Classic Moc’s craftsmanship is excellent, and it is made in the USA, using materials like Nubuck, Oiled and Waxed leather, and Dark Gun Metal Eyelets.

The boot’s outsole is Traction Tred, and it has a split reverse storm welt, making it water-resistant. The boots are resoleable and are built with a No. 45 Last that provides enough room in the footwear to accommodate removable footbeds to adjust the fit.

Overview of Red Wing 875

The Red Wing 875 boot is made with Oro Legacy leather, a proprietary blend of oils that is exclusive to Red Wing.

The full-grain texture of the leather is left on display without any added pigment, showcasing its natural beauty. The boot features a moc toe and Traction Tred outsole, which form a silhouette that sets the standard for all other boots.

The boot was initially made for sportspeople but quickly grew into a favorite of farm and factory workers for its long-lasting construction, steady traction, and all-day comfort. The Classic Moc’s features live on today, as the boot is built with the same pride and process now as it was then.

Moc toe construction and the iconic Traction Tred rubber outsoles lead the way, while Puritan triple-stitching and the Goodyear welt make this boot a legend in durability.

What is the difference between Red Wing 1907 and 875?

The main differences between the Red Wing 1907 and 875 lie in their lasts, insoles, and welt design. The 1907s are built on a more modern and wider 45 last, while the 875s are on the narrower and historic 23 last.

The 1907s feature a removable insole with rubber backing for extra comfort, while the 875s have a leather footbed. Additionally, the 1907s have a non-functional fake Norwegian welt for a rugged appearance, while the 875s have a regular flat welt.

Let’s look at the differences in detail:

Materials

Both the Red Wing 1907 and 875 use oil-tanned leather, which is known for its durability and ability to withstand wear and tear. The Red Wing 1907 features the ‘Copper Rough and Tough’ leather, while the 875 uses the iconic Orolegacy Leather. The leather quality and thickness are similar in both boots, ensuring the same level of protection and longevity.

The 1907’s ‘Copper Rough and Tough’ leather offers a unique, darker hue compared to the 875’s genuine orange shade. The 875’s Oro Legacy Leather is known for its remarkable color transformation over time due to its oil absorption properties, making it an attractive option for those who appreciate a patina that develops with age.

Comfort and Fit

The Red Wing 1907 is generally considered more comfortable than the classic 875, mainly due to its wider and more accommodating last (45). This generous last offers additional interior space, allowing for a more relaxed fit.

The 875, on the other hand, features the historic 23 last, which is narrower and initially less comfortable but may suit those who prefer a slimmer fit.

Another key difference in comfort is the insole. The 1907 comes with a removable insole that provides extra cushioning, making it ideal for long days on your feet.

This added feature also allows for orthotic inserts to be used, catering to those who require personalized support. In contrast, the 875 has a leather footbed without the additional insole, making it slightly less comfortable than the 1907.

Weight and Shoe Construction

When it comes to weight, the Red Wing 1907 is slightly heavier at 67 oz, compared to the 64 oz Red Wing 875. This small difference in weight can be attributed to the 1907’s more robust construction, with its thicker moc-toe stitch, triple white vamp stitch, and double heel cap stitch.

While the weight difference may be noticeable during extended periods of wear, it’s important to consider the benefits of the 1907’s extra sturdiness.

Both boots share unlined shafts, vegetan insoles, cork filling, leather board counters, reversed counter covers, and Puritan stitch construction. These elements contribute to the durability and overall quality of the boots.

Design

Visually, the Red Wing 1907 and 875 have some distinct design differences. The 1907 features a non-functional fake Norwegian welt for a rugged appearance, while the 875 has a regular flat welt.

The Red Wing 1907 also boasts a darker hue in comparison to the genuine orange shade of the 875, which acquires a remarkable color over time due to the oil absorption properties of Oro Legacy leather.

Red Wing 875 boots are good if you are looking for a lower profile and slimmer design.

The eyelets and laces also differ between the two models. The 875 has nickel eyelets and two-tone leather laces, while the 1907 features gunmetal eyelets with Red Wing branding.

These subtle design elements may influence personal preferences when choosing between the two boots.

Insole Variations

As mentioned earlier, the Red Wing 1907 comes with a removable insole that provides additional cushioning and support, enhancing comfort.

The thin removable insole is also great as it allows for more room in the boot.

The Red Wing 875, on the other hand, has a leather footbed without the additional insole. This design choice makes the 875 slightly less comfortable than the 1907 but may still suit those who prefer a more traditional moc-toe boot without extra cushioning.

Midsole and Footbed

The midsole and footbed of the Red Wing 1907 deliver a softer and more responsive feel in comparison to those of the 875. The 1907’s additional cushioning and support, combined with the softer collar and wider last, contribute to a more comfortable overall experience.

While the 875 may not have the same level of cushioning as the 1907, it still offers a well-constructed midsole and footbed that provide adequate support and comfort for daily wear.

Stitching and Construction

The stitching and construction of the Red Wing 1907 and 875 are both top-notch, ensuring durability and a long-lasting product.

The 1907 features a thicker white moc-toe stitch, a triple white vamp stitch, and a double heel cap stitch, providing a more robust construction than the single stitch design of the 875.

Both boots have triple-stitched, bomb-proof construction with thick white stitching on the moc toe and black elsewhere, showcasing the high-quality craftsmanship Red Wing is known for.

Sizing

As previously mentioned, the Red Wing 1907 is built on the more modern 45 last, which is wider and more accommodating. This generous last provides more interior space for a comfortable fit.

On the other hand, the Red Wing 875 is constructed on the historic 23 last, which is narrower and may require some breaking in.

When selecting between the two boots, it’s essential to consider your personal preferences and foot shape, as each last caters to different fit requirements.

Durability

Red Wing boots are well-known for their durability and high-quality materials. Both the 1907 and 875 models offer excellent value, as they are made in the USA using top-notch materials that ensure longevity.

The slight differences in construction, stitching, and design do not compromise the durability of either boot. Both the Red Wing 1907 and 875 are worth the investment and are sure to withstand the test of time.

Similarities between Red Wing 875 and 1907

Despite the differences mentioned earlier, the Red Wing 875 and 1907 share several similarities that make both boots popular choices among enthusiasts. Here are some key aspects where the two models align:

  1. Leather Quality and Thickness: Both the 1907 and 875 boots have similar leather quality and thickness, ensuring durability and a robust feel. The 1907’s Copper Rough and Tough leather and the 875’s Oro Legacy leather are both oil-tanned, requiring some breaking in and providing excellent protection against the elements.
  2. Outsole and Midsole Materials: The two boots share the same outsole and midsole materials, which contribute to the overall comfort, support, and durability of the footwear. The use of high-quality materials in both boots highlights Red Wing’s commitment to producing long-lasting products.
  3. Construction: Both the Red Wing 875 and 1907 feature unlined shafts, vegetan insoles, cork filling, leather board counters, reversed counter covers, and Puritan stitch construction. These elements provide a solid foundation for the boots, ensuring that they can withstand daily wear and tear.
  4. Made in the USA: Red Wing is a proud American brand, and both the 875 and 1907 models are made in the USA using high-quality materials. This commitment to domestic production adds to the value and appeal of the boots for many customers.

Conclusion

In conclusion, both the Red Wing 875 and 1907 moc-toe boots are excellent choices for those seeking durable, high-quality footwear.

The main differences between Red Wing 875 vs 1907 lie in the last, insole, and welt design, as well as some subtle design and comfort variations. When selecting between the two models, it’s essential to consider your personal preferences, foot shape, and desired comfort level.

Leave a Comment